Should Planes Have Family-Only Sections?

TravelingMom with Teens
Why a families-only section might be a good idea.
babySo this story in USA Today asks: Should planes have families-only sections for families flying with kids? My initial reaction was an overwhelming No! But now I'm not so sure.

I hate the idea of segregating or discriminating against anyone for any reason--whether it's a Muslim woman who objects to security screenings or families flying with kids who would be relegated to the back of the plane.

Because, make no mistake about it, that's where we would be. In the back of the plane. Near the smelly lavatories. In seats that don't recline.

But maybe that's the best place for families flying with kids. At least for those of us with kids who are too young to understand the rules of behavior on an airplane.

It actually might be a relief to be in a families-only area. That way, when a kid needs to go to the bathroom--for the third time on the 90-minute flight--you would be crawling over another mom, not that snooty businessman who thinks he's better than you are.

And when the kids need a drink, the galley is just feet away.

Finally, when it's time to unload the aircraft, you can take your sweet time, gathering up all your kid accoutrements and saunder off the flight rather than hearing that snooty guy huff while you try to juggle the carryon, the diaper bag and the baby, all without any help from him.

The quid-pro-quo? Families get to board first. Even ahead of those extra snooty first class passengers.

What do you think?  Leave a comment here and join us Septmber 6 on the TravelingMom Monday Twitter Party from 9-10 EST.  Click here to RSVP for the party and you will be entered to win a nifty prize!
Related Articles/Posts
  • Everyday Adventure...
    When your kids are young, everything is an adventure for them. This makes even everyday things a great opportunity to visit fun, inexpensive places locally for educational field trips....
  • Traveling With a Child With Autism....
    In Max's first year of life, we travelled a lot. It was inexpensive to fly, and he was portable.  Max didn't mind planes - and he was so cute we seemed to get special treatment from airport secur...
  • Summer Vacation Begins!...
    I just got a text from my 16-year-old daughter: "I just took my last final! You own me a mani and a pedi!"  Today is the last day of school for both my daughters. ...
  • Children in First Class?...
    On my recent trip to the TravelingMom bloggers' retreat, I was surprised to find parents with children in the first class cabin on both my flight to and from Orlando. As a business traveler, I enjoy t...
  • Up in the Air in Montana...
    Strange when a Hollywood movie actually becomes your life’s resource guide.  I’m referring to Up in the Air.  It begins with a roller-bag and a guy in a security line, doffing belt, shoes, jacket, unp...

Comments  

 
#6 Lucy Knight 2010-09-06 10:11
I always dreaded being with other kids when on a long flight as you would just get your baby to sleep and another baby would scream right behind them and wake them up I think it is better to be spread out! they can set each other off!
Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
#5 angelina hart 2010-09-05 03:54
As long as the family section did not show the same movie as the rest of the flight! I was in shock and horror on some lame American flight that still had those old monitor boxes for the whole flight to watch a movie at the same time and it was some horrid shoot em up movie with people being graphically murdered as a form of entertainment in plain sight for my kids to watch. I complained and called corporate about showing rated R movies on flights with kids- Hellooo??? but of course I got nuthin' but eye rolls from the flight attendants.
We don't watch much TV so there was no way my little girls could keep their eyes from it. I had to rig up some blankets and all sorts of nonsense...
Having other crying kids around me would be a treat over that situation!
Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
#4 Naomi 2010-09-04 22:03
When our kids were little (infants), it might have been nice to have that option, but now that our kids are experienced travelers (ages 4, 7 and 15) and handle flights like pros, I'd not choose the family only section.
Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
#3 Jenny Block 2010-09-04 20:39
There should DEFINITELY be a family section on the plane for any children who cannot sit still quietly for the of the flight. For those of us who basically fly for a living, it's like having kids in your office!

Of course, I also think that parents should be pretty strict about making sure their kids behave. Too many times I've seen kids running around or babies screaming and parents doing nothing.

I have an 11 year old who travels with me a lot, including internationally . The rule is behave or you don't get to travel. When she was little I did everything I could to keep her behaved. It's simple courtesy.

As for boarding first, I think the back of the plane should board first, but only after first class and Priority passengers. Folks in First and/or with status have earned or paid for that right. It doesn't make sense to offer a "perk" to less frequent flyers over frequent ones.

Warmly, Jenny
Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
#2 Alicia 2010-09-03 11:16
I think it would be great for planes to have family-only sections so long as it's optional AND it's actually a family-friendly section. By family-friendly I mean more room, a TV on every headrest, wireless headphones, hand sanitizer, coloring books & crayons, magazines for the parents, healthy snacks for the kids and a wine cooler (that holds lots of wine for quick and easy access.. even at 11 in the morning) for the moms and dads! I wonder if that will EVER happen? I can dream, right?
Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
#1 Justine Ickes 2010-08-26 13:05
Although I see your point about some of the "benefits" of a family-only section, I definitely wouldn't want to be in a family-only section. When my kids were very young (six-months to 6 years), we managed to make it through several 11+-hour flights. Now that I've survived the years of traveling with very young children, I'm not eager to re-visit those days, even if it's with other people's children.
Quote | Report to administrator
 

Add comment

We reserve the right to delete or edit inappropriate comments.

Security code
Refresh

TravelingMom Video

JoomlaWatch 1.2.12 - Joomla Monitor and Live Stats by Matej Koval
Page Speed 1.44 Seconds

Provided by iJoomla SEO